Project for Chapter 1

Mgt 1500

 

 

A Fracking Fracas: How Much Innovation Is Too Much?

 

As you learned in this chapter, business moves at breakneck speeds. Industrial and technological change is inevitable, and one of the keys to a successful business is a willingness to lean forward and embrace this change. Still, before a company can initiate a change, it must weigh the ethical, financial, and environmental impact of its actions. Neglect of one or more of these factors may lead some to wonder if the pursuit of innovation is always worth its potential consequences. To wit, one of the most controversial business changes in recent years is the oil and gas industry’s move toward hydraulic fracturing as an alternative to traditional well mining.

 

More commonly known as fracking, hydraulic fracturing is a process whereby a pressurized mix of liquid and sand is pumped down a well into sheets of rock located deep below the earth’s surface. As the pressurized mix expands, the liquid breaks the rock apart, creating fissures. The sand mixed into the liquid keeps the fissures from closing in on themselves, creating pathways through which natural gas and other fossil fuels can be extracted. Fracking has been used to stimulate traditional oil well production rates since the 1940s, but the process has only recently become technologically and financially viable as a large-scale, standalone venture.

 

In the United States and Canada, fracking is most commonly used to extract natural gas from sheets of shale rock. Because so many oil and gas companies have turned toward fracking, U.S. natural gas reserves increased by more than 75 percent between 2004 and 2011. The U.S. Energy Information Administration expects this trend to continue, making the U.S. the world’s largest natural gas producer by 2017.

 

Because it provides access to rare fossil fuels that could not otherwise be collected, fracking is flourishing in many parts of the United States and Canada. However, several unsettling findings have brought the practice’s long-term environmental impact into question, and more than a dozen countries (including France, Germany, Spain, and England) and nearly 100 city and state governments in the United States have imposed moratoria or outright banned the practice. Change and innovation are inevitable in business. Without question, fracking represents a change (and an extraordinary innovation) in America’s oil and gas industry. As business moves forward, however, business leaders must consider whether change is always worth the risks it carries.

 

On one hand, fracking poses several benefits to America’s economy and business environment:

·       Without question, fracking is a boon to many American businesses. It has drastically reduced the cost of natural gas across the country, benefiting energy-intensive industries in an otherwise perilous economic climate. Fracking provides the United States a distinct competitive advantage, reducing our dependence on foreign fossil fuels and positioning America as a major player in the global gas market. According to President Barack Obama, the bourgeoning fracking industry will produce 600,000 new jobs nationwide.

·       Because it reduces our dependence on coal, fracking may actually improve the environment. According to the International Energy Agency, replacing America’s coal-burning power plants with natural gas-based plants could reduce emissions of greenhouse gases created through electric generation by as much as 45 percent. “If we combine that step with the other steps that make sense in their effects on both the economy and the environment . . . we will have a reasonable chance of meeting our climate goals,” says George Washington University law professor Richard J Pierce Jr.

 

On the other hand, opponents of fracking point to several compelling scientific studies suggesting that the practice is unsafe:

·       One Duke University study found that water supplies located within a half-mile of fracking wells can become contaminated with unsafe levels of methane: “The gas, which is usually located thousands of feet below the water table, appears to be entering the water wells either through cracks in the bedrock or, more likely, the casing in natural gas wells.” The connection was first discovered when residents living near fracking sites discovered that their running tap water was flammable and could be ignited with a match or lighter.

·       A 2013 study published in the scientific journal Geology found that the injection of pressurized fracking fluid can cause tectonic plates to shift, triggering earthquakes. According to the study, the largest earthquake in Oklahoma’s history (measuring 5.7 on the Richter scale and felt across 17 states) was caused by fracking. Moreover, between 2009 and 2013, the rate of earthquakes recorded in the American Midwest was 11 times higher than the average rate recorded over the previous 30 years.

 

Questions -- Answer some or all of the following questions ( as many as you need to get to 600 words for the assignment)

 

A.Should oil and gas companies be allowed to engage in fracking, or should the Canada ban the practice? Should certain regulations be put in place? Defend your answer using examples from the text.

 

B. While fracking might have flown under the radar during the Industrial Revolution, the relationship era requires companies to build long-term relationships with customers—some of whom may oppose the practice. Imagine that you’re a marketing manager for a gas company that is about to venture into fracking. What steps will you take to maintain current customers? How will you address potential new ones?

 

 

C.  America’s oil and gas companies are among the nation’s largest; Exxon Mobil, Chevron, and Phillips 66 alone generate more than $850 billion in revenue a year. The oil and gas industry is growing rapidly—especially since the introduction of fracking—and many companies are desperate for young business professionals to join their ranks. Would you consider a career in the oil and gas industry? Why or why not? If so, what sort of work would you like to do? If not, what other career path could you see yourself taking?

 

 

 

Sources: “More Evidence Shows Drilling Causes Earthquakes,” by Matthew Philips, BloombergBusinessweek website, http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2013-04-01/more-evidence-that-fracking-causes-earthquakes; “Natural Gas Fracking Addresses All of Our Major Problems,” by Richard J. Pierce, George Washington University website, http://scholarship.law.gwu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1177&context=faculty_publications; “Hydraulic Fracturing of Oil & Gas Wells Drilled in Shale,” Geology.com website, http://geology.com/articles/hydraulic-fracturing; “Scientific Study Links Flammable Drinking Water to Fracking,” by Abraham Lustgarten, ProPublica website, http://www.propublica.org/article/scientific-study-links-flammable-drinking-water-to-fracking/single#republish.

 

Additional Questions if you need them to get to you word limit

 

1.    What factors contribute to the rapid pace of change in business? Is the pace likely to accelerate or decrease over the next decade? Why?

 

 

2.    What role does entrepreneurship play in the economy? Who stands to gain from the success of individual entrepreneurs? How do other parties benefit?